Pete Rose, the all-time MLB hits leader, passed away on Monday at the age of 83, according to TMZ.
The Cincinatti Reds legend was a 17-time All-Star and three-time World Series winner as a player. Anyone else with his résumé would have been a first-ballot Hall of Fame inductee. However, Rose was barred from induction because he bet on baseball as both a player and manager.
That's the dichotomy of Pete Rose. On the one hand, the MLB world is mourning the passing of an all-time great. On the other hand, MLB continues to mourn what Rose's legacy could have been if he hadn't committed one of the cardinal sins of sports.
Amid the tributes that poured in on social media, the debate over Rose's absence in the Baseball Hall of Fame sparked back up.
For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the discord to get the inside scoop between now and the MLB offseason.
MLB fans argue for Pete Rose's Hall of Fame place after passing
Rose was placed on baseball's permanently ineligible list in 1989 when he was the manager of the Reds. The league determined he placed bets on dozens of games during his career as a player and manager. In 2004, he admitted to betting on baseball, including Reds games, though he claimed he only ever bet on his team to win.
Over the decades, fans and media have taken sides on whether Rose should be in the Hall of Fame. Every commissioner since Bart Giamatti has upheld Rose's ban despite calls to put him on the ballot.
Now that Rose has passed, there are plenty who believe the "lifetime" ban should end.
My view on Pete Rose's lifetime ban is that it was supposed to last a lifetime. Now that that's done, get him into the Hall of Fame, where he belongs.
— Matt Welch (@MattWelch) September 30, 2024
Pete Rose died.
— Tim Williams (@timwilliamsart) September 30, 2024
In a Hall of Fame that has some very problematic people (I'm looking at you, Ty Cobb) in it, there isn't any reason Pete shouldn't be enshrined in Cooperstown.
RIP.
— Greg Price (@greg_price11) September 30, 2024
It’s truly one of the biggest travesties in the history of sports that Pete Rose is not in the baseball Hall of Fame https://t.co/bNPCbHOKxJ
RIP Pete Rose.
— The Degenerates (@degen_betting) September 30, 2024
Utterly ridiculous he was never inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.
MLB needs to do what’s right and put him in now. Better late than never. pic.twitter.com/vtAfWnh3PT
Pete Rose should have been inducted into the Hall of Fame the moment FanDuel became the official sports betting partner of Major League Baseball.
— Andrew Lind (@AndrewMLind) September 30, 2024
The groundswell of support for Rose's posthumous induction is significant. The question is whether Rob Manfred will budge on the longstanding policy of excluding him.
Personally, I think Rose's ban from baseball was perfectly warranted. There was never any doubt about betting on the game being off limits. Rose chose to break that cardinal rule and paid for it for the remainder of his life. It doesn't really matter that MLB now has partnerships with sports betting operations. As a player or manager, you're still not allowed to bet on baseball. That hasn't changed.
Having said that, Rose is a part of the story of baseball. Putting him in Cooperstown now wouldn't be letting him off easy. He did his time. His legend is more than just the mistakes.