NBA Trade Deadline 2018: 5 worst trade deadline deals ever
4. February 2006: Steve Francis to the Knicks; Penny Hardaway and Trevor Ariza to the Magic
At the 2006 trade deadline the Knicks, in classic Knicks fashion, tried to make a splash by acquiring a big name player. And as with most moves in the Isiah Thomas era, New York’s decision to trade for former All-Star Steve Francis was mostly a disaster.
The trade worked out well for the Magic, who unloaded Francis’ hefty multi-year contract and got Penny Hardway’s expiring deal and young Trevor Ariza in return. Ariza played just under 100 games for the Magic and didn’t contribute that much to a team that would soon become a juggernaut in the East; moving on from Francis and reorienting the franchise around Dwight Howard were certainly enough to make this trade a success for the Magic though.
Things did not go nearly as well in New York. The player the Knicks received was not the three-time All Star guard that they were hoping for. Francis regressed throughout his tenure with the Knicks, struggling under Larry Brown in 2006 before falling off a statistical cliff when Isiah Thomas took over as Knicks coach in 2006-2007. Francis averaged just 11 points per game in 68 appearances for New York and made $15 million per season during that time. In addition, pairing two combustible personalities like Stephon Marbury and Steve Francis was never a particularly good idea. The Knicks predictably struggled to win under the leadership of two guys that don’t have a history of sacrificing for the team, to put things lightly.