One 2024 NFL Draft pick every team already regrets and why

It is way too early to call any NFL Draft pick a bust, but it is not too early to say we're "worried" about certain picks. Some teams have even completely given up on players they just took.
2024 NFL Draft - Round 1
2024 NFL Draft - Round 1 / Gregory Shamus/GettyImages
facebooktwitterreddit
Prev
21 of 32
Next

Minnesota Vikings - JJ McCarthy
First Round Pick

Regret is such a strong word, but one has to wonder how the Minnesota Vikings feel right now. They are playing incredibly well with Sam Darnold at quarterback. He just had a four-touchdown game, and he’s helped the Vikings remain undefeated after the first three weeks of the season. The Vikings might be the surprise of the league so far, and some are considering a Sam Darnold extension in Minnesota. 

That would be enough to make the J.J. McCarthy pick regrettable, but it’s the fact that Darnold was unimpeded to the starting job because McCarthy suffered a major injury in preseason that has him firmly on this list. He suffered a knee injury in his first preseason game, and that’s opened the door for Darnold to thrive with Justin Jefferson and Company.

The Vikings defense is doing some heavy lifting here, too. They are a major reason the team is 3-0 at the time of this writing, but the fact that Darnold has avoided mistakes and has been hitting the end zone with consistency is huge. 

The Vikings could have had tight end Brock Bowers, defensive lineman Laiatu Latu, edge rusher Jared Verse, or one of the many offensive tackles who went outside the top 10. Instead, at least for this season, they have nothing to show for the 10th-overall pick.