NBA One-and-Done Rule: Why the NBA and NCAA Need to Get It Right

Mandatory Credit: Geoff Burke-USA TODAY Sports

With the 5th pick of the 1995 NBA Draft, the Minnesota Timberwolves select Kevin Garnett, forward from Farragut Academy HS, Chicago, Illinois.

And with that our modern day shape of basketball was changed as for the first time in 20 years a high schooler was drafted. Garnett would go onto become a 15 time All-Star, 4 time All-NBA 1st Teamer, 2008 Defensive Player of the Year and the 2003 NBA MVP. With the selection of Kobe Bryant and Jermaine O’Neal the following season,two people you may have heard of, the era of high school kids skipping college began.

I think back to an article Steve Kerr wrote about this rule of having to wait a year upon graduating high school to enter the NBA Draft. He had two quick stories, one was about a young player who was shocked they didn’t get to go home for Christmas, the other was about this one new guy who didn’t know what a best of 5 series was.

And that’s the thing about this rule, it’s not that these guys physically and talent wise are not NBA ready, it’s that mentally they are usually far off from being ready to play professional sports.

Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

You know in life you grow up in stages, the first is high school, when you begin to actually take on some responsibilities while still being in that bubble of protection from your parents and school environment. Then college is when you become your own person really, yet still usually have that kind of parental support to fall back on.

Being a person in their early 20s, most sports fans can relate to these guys who want to go to the NBA, but at the same time you think back about where you were when you just got out of high school.

My first semester of college was awful, I barely paid attention, the effort was minimal, and I worked small hours doing an easy job. However I grew up, got a much better job, and started bringing home good grades, and eventually matured into a productive adult. Yet that’s small potatoes compared to what these kids have to do, playing an 82 game schedule against grown men with years, if not decades of experience.

Then there is the traveling across country from October to April at the very least, sometimes all the way through mid June, while being hounded by media personnel constantly. And then there’s dealing with your contract, dealing with agents, old friends who have a great new “business plan”, and most of all family back home who wants some cash their way.

Say what you will about college, but the schedule of 15 credit hours and 30 basketball games is the perfect workload needed to instill proper discipline for these 18 year olds, and that discipline is what you need to properly handle adversity through the fame and fortune a pro career has to offer.

The best thing about the one and done rule is it seems to be producing a more NBA-ready class, improving league play.

Mandatory Credit: Mark D. Smith-USA TODAY Sports

Kevin Durant exploded onto the stage immediately ready to take over, averaging 20.3 a game, numbers that only LeBron could equal to in his rookie season compared to the other prep-to-one and done and the modern basketball player pro greats. KG went 10 & 6 a game, Kobe averaged just 7.6 PPG and Dwight Howard averaged just 12PPG and 10 rebounds a game. Derrick Rose, another one and done player, in his first year averaged 17PPG, 6.3 APG and 4 RPG, Westbrook that season also averaged 15.3 PPG and then 5 rebounds and assists per game as well.

Then you’ve got John Wall who could have easily left high school to the pros if he wanted in the days before the rule existed, put up tremendous numbers at Kentucky, before going to the NBA and averaging 16.4 PPG and 8.3 APG in his first year at Washington.

Listen I could keep going, listing player after player since 2006 that has made a big immediate impact, but I think you get the point. It’s that simply the best players have been made even better by that one year of college, to see a rookie come in and put up terrific numbers isn’t shocking anymore, yet during the prep-to-pro era we saw years of a weaker rookie crop that took a few years to get going. I mean athletes aren’t going to hit a solid stride anyways until maybe 20 or 21 at the earliest, what’s wrong with an extra year of development before going into the pros?

From the age of 16 to 19 my golf averages for 18 holes were 98, 86, 82 & 78. The reason for this is simple: it doesn’t matter who you are and what level you play sports at because as you get older your body fills out, and the way you think while you play changes. John Wall said it best by stating that, “I think college … on and off the court, made me become the best person”, and when you look at it, most of these guys who played a year in college haven’t had the maturity issues guys like LeBron, Kobe and Dwight Howard have had.

Mandatory Credit: Mark Zerof-USA TODAY Sports

Everyone who played with Kobe essentially wound up hating him it seems, Dwight has had nothing but drama the last few years with how poorly he handled the Orlando situation, and now his failure to re-sign in LA. And then LeBron basically gave the city of Cleveland the finger on basic cable by “taking his talents to South Beach”.

This rule does have tons of controversy, I get that, but the NBA is a company so who are we to question this? I mean we all have had a job, and to get that job you have to meet a certain set of requirements listed by the company you’re applying to. I wouldn’t be writing this column unless I didn’t have previous writing and reporting experience. So my question is why can’t the NBA have a certain requirement on the level of experience needed to get employment with them? And who are we to judge a company who wants their future employees to develop another year, mature another year, and do it all off the payroll in the NCAA or other foreign leagues.

I know we all love the NBA, so who’s really got a problem with a better brand of athletes and basketball? That seems to have been and forever be the multi-million dollar question.

Written by Thomas Schulte

Topics: John Wall, Kevin Durant, Kevin Garnett, Kobe Bryant, Lebron James, NBA, NBA Draft 2012, NCAA

Want more from FanSided?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • eriksuperman

    For most athletes, going to college for a year or two offers
    SO many more opportunities to learn and grow as a player/person than simply
    entering the draft a proverbial baby. I’m not saying it can’t work out
    for those select few (See: Kobe, Garnett, etc.), but most players need a bit of
    structure, and not unfettered millions to spend as a teenager. That being
    said, I still love basketball, and don’t have much of an issue with too many
    players/teams in this respect. I’ve been watching a ton of KG games this year,
    in part because this is his last season most likely, and in part to juxtapose
    HIS attitudes and skills as a player with those OTHER kids who are starting
    down the same path. I have been watching this play out all season, and
    while the select few individuals who CAN do this are thriving, most are
    not. I’ve been using my new Game Finder app on the DISH Hopper to find
    games outside my home market, and have gotten the chance to see a lot of games
    I wouldn’t have otherwise spent the time to find. DISH Game Finder helps
    me find any sports to watch on TV, whether it be the ‘big four’ sports or
    college athletics, and while I work late at DISH most nights, I can store up to
    2,000 hours of TV on my DISH Hopper. I’ve been watching a ton of games,
    and it’s a lot of fun having the DVR find them all for me.

21 minutes ago

NFL Draft Rumors: Green Bay Packers unlikely to draft tackle

27 minutes ago

TUF Nations Finale: Main card predictions and preview

34 minutes ago

NFL Draft Rumors: New York Jets to visit with Odell Beckham Jr