43. <p>This might be controversial, but it shouldn’t be. Tanaka lags behind the rest of the AL contenders in strikeouts, and that does matter. The right-hander ranks well outside the top tier with only 7.71 strikeouts per 9 innings, but on the flip side, Tanaka lands third in walk rate at only 1.49 per 9 innings. That leads to top-three marks in fWAR (5.0) and bWAR (5.1) and cements his candidacy for me. Throw-in a very nice 3.04 ERA and I’m sold.</p>. SP. New York Yankees. Masahiro Tanaka. 3. player