25 worst college football coaching hires in history
4. Jennings B. Whitworth, Alabama
- Hired: December 1954
- Fired: 1957
- Record at Alabama: 4-24-2 (.133)
- Career head coaching record: 26-51-4 (.333)
A lineman at Alabama in the early 1930s and part of the Crimson Tide’s 1930 Rose Bowl squad, J.B. Whitworth – also known as “Ears” – was an assistant coach for the Crimson Tide, LSU and Georgia (where he also served a short stint as head baseball coach) for nearly two decades before he was hired as the head coach at Oklahoma A&M (now Oklahoma State) in 1950.
Whitworth compiled a modest 22-27-2 with the Cowboys, including a share of the Missouri Valley Conference title in 1953, and was hired away by his alma mater to replace Red Drew, who had been removed from the position following a disappointing 4-5-2 campaign in 1954.
Remarkably, it would take all of Whitworth’s three seasons on the Alabama sidelines to match Drew’s ’56 win total. Alabama was 0-10 in 1955, was shut out four times and managed to score just 48 points all season. Whitworth’s 1956 squad lost its first four games, giving the Tide an astonishing 0-14 start to his career, and pushing Alabama’s winless streak to 20 before a 13-12 win over Mississippi State.
The Crimson Tide finished 2-7-1 in both 1956 and 1957, when Whitworth was fired. His final game was a 40-0 loss to No. 1 and eventual national champion Auburn, and Whitworth’s squad was outscored 100-7 Tigers over three seasons.
Though he was hamstrung by a meddling administration that limited his ability to hire assistants, Whitworth also famously benched all of his seniors, including legendary quarterback Bart Starr, On a positive note, Whitworth’s three-year tenure in Tuscaloosa set the stage for Bear Bryant, who took over prior to the 1958 season and quickly turned the Crimson Tide into annual national championship contenders.