Fans up in Columbus were up in arms when they found out that Ohio State was left out of the College Football Playoff despite winning the Big Ten.
Heading into Conference Championship Week, the top four teams were Clemson, Oklahoma, Auburn and Wisconsin. As long as those four teams held serve the College Football Playoff Committee had an easy decision to make. But with Georgia beating Auburn, they’re in. The toughest decision they had to make was whether Alabama or Ohio State should get that last spot.
Even though a two-loss team has never made the Playoff, many believed Ohio State would get in. They got the benefit of the doubt in 2014 when they made it over TCU, and in 2016 when they got in despite not winning their own conference. The Playoff Committee face a very similar decision this year, in that they have to choose between a two-loss conference champion or a one-loss team that’s better on paper.
In the end, the Committee went with Alabama at No. 4, setting up a trilogy match between them and Clemson.
And you’d best believe Buckeyes fans had a lot to say.
Ohio State has only itself to blame by losing by 31 to Iowa. But the Alabama-is-clearly-better argument is a soft one. Very few thought OSU would beat Bama in 2014 CFP.
— Bill Rabinowitz 🗞 (@brdispatch) December 3, 2017
Conference championships don't matter... except when they help the TV ratings.#CFBPlayoff
— Matt Zemek (@MattZemek) December 3, 2017
Ohio State's conference title mattered in 2014 when TCU was the alternative... but not when Bama was there
This is about TV & making $ for (and from) ESPN.
Let's not pretend otherwise.
The #CFBPlayoff Committee, when they’re asked why they chose Alabama when they didn’t win their conference and didn’t beat anyone over conference champs Ohio State and USC: pic.twitter.com/x7IJGYHwdB
— NOTSportsCenter (@NOTSportsCenter) December 3, 2017
I'm no Ohio State fan. BUT THE BUCKEYES JUST GOT ALL-TIME ROBBED OF THE FOURTH SPOT IN THE PLAYOFFS. OHIO STATE IS BETTER THAN ALABAMA, WHICH GOT DOMINATED BY AUBURN AND WHOSE DEFENSE GAVE UP 150+ RUSHING THE LAST THREE GAMES.
— Skip Bayless (@RealSkipBayless) December 3, 2017
Clemson fans seeing they have to play Alabama instead of Ohio State pic.twitter.com/7GOf6KWvwV
— ASGI Guy (@AsgiGuy) December 3, 2017
Alabama would not beat Ohio State
— Collin (@CollinPowers5) December 3, 2017
Alabama would not beat Wisconsin
The #CFBPlayoff is so rigged, Bama doesn't deserve No.4, Ohio State Deserved that spot. I guess the committee f*cked Nick Saban's Cousin
— Jacob Manchester (@JakeManchester3) December 3, 2017
Ohio State, you are not a friend of the crown.... #Dillydilly
— Bryant Rogers (@Bryant_Rogers1) December 3, 2017
“What is: THE Ohio State University?”#JeopardySports #CFBPlayoff pic.twitter.com/uuWbzHHUbn
— Jeopardy! Sports (@JeopardySports) December 3, 2017
Don't lose to Iowa by 31 points, don't leave your playoff odds to the committee. Ohio State has no one to blame but itself.
— Ben Axelrod (@BenAxelrod) December 3, 2017
By leaving Ohio State and and putting Alabama in, the College Football Playoff committee snubbed the Big Ten entirely while having two SEC teams. It may not seem fair, but that’s the direction they were going in for much of the season when they started ranking.
In the end, the Playoff committee took the safer approach. They let in a team with one loss instead of two, and a team whose worst loss came to Auburn instead of Iowa.
Next: 30 bucket list items for college football fans
Ohio State fans may feel hard done by, but let’s not forget that they were on the other end of this equation a year ago. With that in mind, they’ll surely be rooting for Clemson to take down Alabama 31-0 now.