5 possible replacements for Jon Gruden on Monday Night Football
3. Pat McAfee
The former Indianapolis Colts punter would be an unconventional choice but a great fit. Pat McAfee has always had a great sense of humor about being in the NFL and being a punter, not exactly a glamour position. This could be sort of awkward at the start since McAfee is currently with Barstool Sports. ESPN gave Barstool a spot on their channel for all of one episode before they canceled the show. It stands to reason it wasn’t the smoothest discussion behind the scenes. Shows don’t get the greenlight and canceled within one episode if everything goes right. That still shouldn’t stop McAfee from being a serious candidate.
During his playing days, McAfee made the Pro Bowl twice and was one of the best punters in the league. That’s not exactly the same as being a running back or a safety, but he was still a great player in the NFL. He would have plenty of knowledge of the intricacies of the game and would be able to relay that in an incisive and humorous way. His sarcasm and wit would likely help cover any gaps in broadcasting knowledge and it would be entertaining to hear him in this setting. He may not be a Tony Romo-style broadcaster but he would be something new and different.