NFL Twitter had some wild reactions to Gardner Minshew trade
By Josh Hill
![Gardner Minshew, Jacksonville Jaguars. (Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports) Gardner Minshew, Jacksonville Jaguars. (Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports)](https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/c_fill,w_720,ar_16:9,f_auto,q_auto,g_auto/shape/cover/sport/c54fc96a8c38c44c100252757e9facc2ce6576a6c55b8fd759a0530f85e4223e.jpg)
The Eagles pulled the trigger on a Gardner Minshew trade that has NFL Twitter both confused but also intrigued by what happens next.
With two weeks to go before the start of the new NFL season, the Eagles and Jaguars gave us our first big 11th hour roster move.
Gardner Minshew, who created a wave of Minshew Mania two years ago, was traded to Philadelphia for a conditional sixth-round pick that could be as high as a fifth-rounder. The Jaguars, with Trevor Lawrence as their starter, viewed C.J. Beathard as the better backup option and scheme fit for whatever Urban Meyer is cooking up in Duval.
That meant Minshew was expendable, and the Eagles surprisingly picked him up despite already having a starter (Jalen Hurts) and a multimillion dollar backup (Joe Flacco).
The reactions to the trade ranged from fans in Philly wondering what exactly adding Minshew to a crowded and expensive quarterback room does, to observations about how the Jaguars might have already bungled Trevor Lawrence’s early development by not making a Minshew move earlier.
NFL Twitter reacts to Gardner Minshew trade
eagles backup situation is a little weird considering what that offense will look like for jalen hurts. https://t.co/ZK1y9XH9eB
— Steven Ruiz (@theStevenRuiz) August 28, 2021
thoughts:
— Warren Sharp (@SharpFootball) August 28, 2021
the Jags were VERY DUMB to limit Trevor Lawrence's reps in practice & games to work in time for a guy you were going to trade...for a 6th???
conditional 6th for Minshew is ridiculously low
former Jags GM? he's now in Philly
Minshew is better than you think
thievery https://t.co/iwkKXvX6vi
if I'm trying to get the heralded best QB prospect in several years ready to start week 1...
— Warren Sharp (@SharpFootball) August 28, 2021
the last thing I'm doing is stealing reps from him to give to a QB I think so highly of...
that I'm willing to deal him for a <checks notes> 6th rd pick
help me Urban it makes no sense
I'm surprised the #Jaguars only got a conditional late pick for Gardner Minshew.
— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) August 28, 2021
Has starting experience, showed a knack for big plays. Has 38 total career TDs to only 11 INTs.
Still two years of cheap contract left..pic.twitter.com/ALu80ZudG0
Giants are gonna roll with their QB who’s worse than Gardner Minshew while the Eagles get Minshew as their backup, huh? Neat. pic.twitter.com/LibUS1R5pQ
— Adam Weinrib (@AdamWeinrib) August 28, 2021
You’re exactly right about the QB “competition” in Jacksonville. Lawrence should have gotten every single rep from the start https://t.co/hX3xhdTlSA
— Geoff Schwartz (@geoffschwartz) August 28, 2021
Perhaps the strangest part about the trade is the fact that the Eagles didn’t need Minshew on the depth chart. He no doubt adds great value in the quarterback room, but Philly paid Joe Flacco $3.5 million this offseason to come in and back up Hurts — a plan that doesn’t seem to be changing.
#Eagles committed 3.5M to Joe Flacco so I wouldn’t view the addition of Gardner Minshew as a new top backup to Jalen Hurts. Minshew (850k in 2021) is QB3.#QBFactory
— Geoff Mosher (@GeoffPMosher) August 28, 2021
Minshew and Flacco backing up Hurts likely gives new Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni some peace of mind when it comes to what might happen if things go awry. Hurts has two smart quarterbacks to help his development as a starter, and having three starting quarterbacks in its quarterback room surely won’t stoke any local sports talk radio coals and create beautifully entertaining chaos this season.