Why does the Miguel Cabrera intentional walk make sense? In a pure baseball sense, it does, even if the baseball Gods smite Yankees manager Aaron Boone in the aftermath.
Cabrera had three earlier at-bats to register his 3,000th career hit, but failed to do so. Miggy struck out twice and flew out in his first at-bat. In his final chance of the afternoon against the Yankees, Boone opted to intentionally walk him instead of potentially witnessing history.
Why would Boone do such a thing? Was it merely a cop-out, knowing the Yankees were headed out of town on Thursday night?
No. Despite all the boos which rained down from the Comerica Park stands, Boone’s decision makes sense, in theory. But that doesn’t necessarily make it right.
Lucas Luetge: Miguel Cabrera intentional walk, explained
Luetge is a left-handed pitcher, while Miggy is a future Hall of Famer from the right side of the dish. On the surface, this really isn’t that hard to understand, and it’s surely the excuse Boone will use despite the fact most fans and even some baseball media were furious at him in the moment.
Someone break out the unwritten rules regarding an IW in the 8th inning when the batter is sitting on 2999 hits! Boo Aaron Boone. (It backfired anyway)
— Jesse Rogers (@JesseRogersESPN) April 21, 2022
Look, made sense from Aaron Boone's perspective.
— Cody Stavenhagen (@CodyStavenhagen) April 21, 2022
But the baseball gods did not smile on this decision. Meadows had a bloop hit fall in CF. Two runs score. 3-0 Tigers.
"Yankees suck," chants at Comerica. https://t.co/ikLkzmv53e
Austin Meadows, meanwhile, is a left-handed hitter, and routinely struggles against lefties. So, Boone had Luetge face the lefty in Meadows. In any other situation, it would’ve been a no-brainer. But because Miggy was sitting on 2,999 hits, the baseball Gods frowned upon him and the Yankees.
Or something like that.
Meadows made the Yankees pay, if you can even call it that. The left-handed hitter blooped in a single in the most sure-handed baseball karma Detroit has ever seen.
Yankees intentionally walk Miguel Cabrera then Austin Meadows dunks in a two-run single
— Talkin’ Baseball (@TalkinBaseball_) April 21, 2022
"Yankees suck" chants rain down at Comerica pic.twitter.com/woJSilUfE7
Yes, Cabrera will have to wait for his 3,000th hit, but thankfully the Tigers are in the middle of a homestand.
Next up? The Colorado Rockies.