NFL trade grades: Eagles land star safety from Saints in shocking move

The Philadelphia Eagles made a surprising trade on NFL cut day, landing Chauncey Gardner-Johnson, formerly on the New Orleans Saints.

Gardner-Johnson wanted a new contract to stay in New Orleans, but those talks reportedly broke down in the middle of training camp. The two sides were engaged in what many considered a hold-in, rather than a holdout, where Gardner-Johnson still participated in camp but in a limited capacity.

With neither side willing to budge, New Orleans got what they could from the Eagles in a trade. He’s their problem now, and a welcomed addition at that rate.

In a corresponding move, Philadelphia released Anthony Harris, thanks in part to the addition of Gardner-Johnson.

NFL trade grades: Eagles acquire Chauncey Gardner-Johnson from Saints

While we don’t yet know the draft pick compensation for Gardner-Johnson, it’s fair to consider the Eagles winners of this trade as they are filling an obvious hole in their secondary. Gardner-Johnson is one of the better safeties in the NFC.

New Orleans, meanwhile, could not pony up the necessary spending to keep Gardner-Johnson. This, despite draft capital surely headed their way, makes them the losers of this deal.

https://twitter.com/AdamSchefter/status/1564638932893057026

Eagles: A-

It’s tough to argue with the grade above, as Philadelphia filled a much-needed gap in their defense. It’s been an active offseason for Howie Roseman, specifically on the trade market. Earlier this offseason he acquired AJ Brown from the Tennessee Titans, as well.

Now, whether or not Philly can sign Gardner-Johnson long-term will determine how successful this trade can be for them. He’s set to make just over $2 million this season, a severe underpay, and is a free agent after the year.

A contract extension should come in short order. Given how much safeties were paid this offseason, Gardner-Johnson will not come cheap.

Saints: C+

The Saints received two late-round picks in exchange for Gardner-Johnson, and even had to throw in their own pick in 2025. That’s rather lackluster, and surely not enough for a player of Gardner-Johnson’s caliber.