With the New York Yankees on the brink of elimination, outfielder Harrison Bader came up huge. Bader hit a two-run homer to give the Yanks a 3-0 lead.
New York acquired Harrison Bader at the trade deadline in a surprising move which sent Jordan Montgomery to the St. Louis Cardinals. For quite some time, Montgomery and the Cards were viewed as the winners of that trade, if only because Bader was injured.
Montgomery, meanwhile, got off to an impressive start with St. Louis before fading down the stretch. The 29-year-old pitcher was a Yankees clubhouse favorite ā so much so that his now-former teammates openly rooted for him in the locker room shortly after the deal.
Cashman didnāt take clubhouse culture into account when he dealt for Bader, and initially, it backfired. But Bader has fit in quite well this postseason, and hit his third home run on Sunday night in Game 4.
Harrison Bader has homered again! #postseason pic.twitter.com/NhciU0DvqT
ā MLB (@MLB) October 16, 2022
Yankees fans think they won Harrison Bader-Jordan Montgomery trade
After all three Bader home runs this postseason, Montgomeryās name has been brought to the forefront by fans ā perhaps a little prematurely ā looking back on the deal made by Cashman.
Who really won said trade? Both teams benefitted, as the Cardinals needed pitching, and New York wanted outfield depth. Bader is a tremendous talent, especially defensively, when healthy. And he grew up in Bronxville, NY.
Home runs this postseason:
ā gabe (@PlayoffTanaka_) October 16, 2022
ā¢Jordan Montgomery: 0
ā¢Harrison Bader: 3
Idk what a Jordan Montgomery is anymore, but this kid from Bronxville is FILTHY
ā Joey (@DJLeMVP) October 16, 2022
Harrison Bader now has 3 more playoff homers as a Yankee than Jordan Montgomery.
ā Jake Asman (@JakeAsman) October 16, 2022
HOW COULD THIS TEAM TRADE JORDAN MONTGOMERY FOR AN INJURED CENTER FIELDER
ā Jetah Fan (@JetahFan_2009) October 16, 2022
You all failed to realize Bader is quite literally him.
After Jordan Montgomeryās first four games with the Cardinals, he posted a 4.97 ERA in seven games
ā Joon Lee (@joonlee) October 16, 2022
Meanwhile, Harrison Bader has three homers in ALDS
The winners of a trade arenāt decided after just a month
Yankees won the Jordan Montgomery trade. Not even a debate anymore.
ā Nick (@NYYNick_) October 16, 2022
Everyone on this app cried for months that the Yankees traded away Jordan Montgomery
ā Kenny Ducey (@KennyDucey) October 16, 2022
Jordan Montgomery who?
ā Chris Kirschner (@ChrisKirschner) October 16, 2022
HARRISON BADER > JORDAN MONTGOMERY
ā Nick Pollack (@PitcherList) October 16, 2022
Harrison Bader has 3 HR in 4 games against the #Guardians and Jordan Montgomery didnāt pitch a game in the postseason. Like I said before, it was a great move. Love him. New #Yankees center fielder. #RepBX
ā Evan Mattel (@Evan_Mattel21) October 16, 2022
All of a sudden, Cashman looks much better for his vision, which included Bader playing centerfield in New York for years to come.
By no means should fans slight Montgomery, however, given he also played a vital role for an eventual postseason team. The Cardinals faults are now his to bare alone. I officially declare this trade a tie.