Every NFL team’s biggest villain ever
Indianapolis Colts: K Mike Vanderjagt
The Kicker? Yup, Peyton Manning’s “Idiot Kicker.” Please note that even those responsible for sending the ball through the uprights are also considered for this list, and this kicker is no exception. At one point, he was indeed “Money Mike.” Regardless of the situation, again, at one point, Vanderjagt would come through.
But then, like most who fall flat on their face, he started to run his mouth several times in the postseason, and it backfired badly. Even in their big overtime win over Tampa Bay in 2003, it took the “Leaping” penalty combined with immense luck on the ensuing kick to make up for the missed kick he had done prior. Kickers can be heroes and come up big in the clutch, but they can also be villains. It just depends on the situation.