Cardinals rumors: Grading 3 potential Paul Goldschmidt blockbuster trades

Grade this trade: B

It’s not the best trade package for the Cards, but it’s likely the most realistic one. Houston doesn’t have to trade any top prospects, but they do deal their top pitching prospect, a 24-year-old who is dealing at the MLB level, and Forrest Whitley. Whitley has been on the verge of MLB action many times, but injuries and setbacks in the minors have limited his playing time.

Overall, Brown could slide right into the top of the Cards rotation in place of Flaherty, who is a free agent after this season. Gordon is a year away from the majors, but could be a middle rotation starter if developed correctly. And it’s impossible to deny Whitley’s potential, assuming he can stay healthy. For now, though, he’s in his mid-20’s and ranks No.15 on Houston’s prospect list for a reason.

The Astros get their first baseman, as Jose Abreu has been dreadful this season. Flaherty can pitch some meaningful games for a very, very injured rotation.