Fansided

Heat-Warriors swap involving Jimmy Butler is beginning to take shape

One simple player swap would solve two team's problems.

By Joseph Kallan

Dec 16, 2024; Detroit, Michigan, USA; Miami Heat forward Jimmy Butler (22) walks off the court after the game against the Detroit Pistons at Little Caesars Arena. Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images
Dec 16, 2024; Detroit, Michigan, USA; Miami Heat forward Jimmy Butler (22) walks off the court after the game against the Detroit Pistons at Little Caesars Arena. Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images / Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images
facebooktwitterreddit

Tensions between Jimmy Butler and the Miami Heat appear to have reached a boiling point, as both sides remain far apart on his future with the franchise. Earlier this season, Butler reportedly requested a trade, but team president Pat Riley dismissed the notion, opting to focus on winning games rather than entertaining potential deals. However, it’s becoming clear that Butler has other plans after once again claiming he'd rather play anywhere else other than Miami.

The Heat star’s recent performances have raised eyebrows, with the exception of a 35-point outing against the Detroit Pistons. Over his last five games, Butler's shot selection has narrowed, leading to lackluster offensive performances which have hurt the team’s overall record. At 35 years old, Butler seems to have lost his spark in Miami and is now seeking a new team—one where he can thrive without the friction of clashing with Riley.

While Riley appears reluctant to move Butler, preferring instead to see the six-time All-Star recommit to the Heat’s goals, a potential trade with the Golden State Warriors could resolve the stalemate and benefit both franchises.

Subscribe to The Whiteboard, FanSided’s daily email newsletter on everything basketball. If you like The Whiteboard, share it with a friend! If you don’t like it, share it with an enemy.

Proposed Trade: Butler to Golden State

  • Golden State Warriors receive: Jimmy Butler
  • Miami Heat receive: Jonathan Kuminga, 2026 first-round pick

The Warriors have long been on Butler’s list of preferred destinations, as he’s eager to join a team with championship aspirations and another superstar alongside whom he can thrive. Playing with Stephen Curry and Draymond Green in Golden State’s system—built around off-ball movement and perimeter shooting—could reignite Butler’s passion and elevate his game.

For Miami, this trade would bring back a promising young forward in Jonathan Kuminga, who is averaging a career-high 16.9 points per game off the bench, along with a valuable future first-round pick. Kuminga's ability to stretch the floor and score at will could make him a cornerstone piece for the Heat moving forward.

Why Golden State should make the move

The Warriors, currently struggling at 17-16 and 3-7 over their last 10 games, are in desperate need of a shakeup. While they recently acquired Dennis Schroder, his underwhelming production of 9.9 points on 32.5% shooting hasn’t addressed their deeper issues.

Adding Butler to their lineup would immediately bolster the team’s defensive versatility and provide a secondary scoring option behind Curry. Butler’s game thrives when he can operate as a complementary star rather than carrying the load as the primary option, a role that aligns perfectly with Golden State’s needs. Despite his perceived discontent, Butler is still averaging 17.6 points on an efficient 55.2% shooting—numbers any team would welcome.

Moreover, the Warriors’ hesitance to commit to a long-term extension for Kuminga signals a lack of clarity about his future role. Moving the young forward for a proven All-Star like Butler could maximize their current championship window, which may be closing as Curry and Green near the twilight of their careers.

What’s in It for Miami?

For the Heat, the trade would not only resolve the ongoing tension with Butler but also provide a promising young talent in Kuminga. At just 21 years old, Kuminga has shown the ability to score efficiently and could fit seamlessly into Miami’s system alongside Tyler Herro, who has taken a significant leap as the team’s top offensive option this season.

Pat Riley faces a tough decision: he can risk losing Butler in free agency without compensation or move him now to secure a player with high upside and a future asset. While Butler has been instrumental in Miami’s success over the years, his growing dissatisfaction threatens to overshadow the team’s focus and cohesion.

What’s next?

The clock is ticking for Miami to make a decision. If Butler’s discontent continues to impact his performance and the team’s chemistry, the Heat may have no choice but to explore a trade. For Golden State, acquiring Butler could be the boost they need to make one final championship push in the Curry era.

Whether Riley and the Heat are ready to pull the trigger remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: time is running out to find a resolution that works for everyone involved.

Home/Miami Heat