The New York Mets lose the same game every season. Yes, I am serious. As Mets fans have pointed out, the team loses their 34th game of the season seemingly every year. Actually, you can remove seemingly – it's happened 15 years in a row. On Sunday, home plate umpire Jim Wolf made sure of it, as Pete Alonso had several questionable pitches go against him in the bottom of the eighth with runners on.
With the bases loaded, Alonso really should have known better than to take such close pitches. However, Wolf also...could have called any one of those a ball, specifically the eighth pitch of the at-bat.
For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the discord to get the inside scoop during the MLB season.
Mets and Pete Alonso have an argument that they got hosed
Wolf is a veteran and knows what he is doing, in general, but the close ball and strike calls are an argument in favor of ABS, if anything. Why risk a result in a one-run game when it's not necessary? We all love the human element of baseball. Mistakes happen all the time. However, both the Mets and Cardinals have a claim at this eighth pitch. There was no correct call to make by a human source, and that is part of the problem.
Alonso's questionable call wasn't the only decision which went against the Mets.
Pete’s strike call was borderline. The strike 1 call at Acuna’s AB was just egregious. pic.twitter.com/yd83q8AQes
— Ian Chiang (@IanEChiang) May 4, 2025
Juan Soto has struck out looking with men on base twice today, to end the inning each time.
— Mets Analytics (@MetsAnalytics) May 4, 2025
Here are the two called strike-threes, sweeper and slider respectively:#LGM pic.twitter.com/9X4kRX6sDS
Yes, even Juan Soto gets bad calls.
Again, it doesn't help that the Mets have lost their 34th game of the season for half of my lifetime. It also doesn't help that Alonso, for some reason, opted to sit on the eighth pitch of the at-bat rather than at the very least extending his plate appearance.
But in a one-run affair, every at-bat is bound to be scrutinized. A walk would have tied the game for the Mets, and perhaps sent us to extra innings. Instead, New York's best attempt to tie was wasted, and one can argue Wolf took the bat out of Alonso's hands.