Every Philadelphia Phillies fan held their breath in dreadful anticipation on Friday night when star closer Jhoan Durán came up limping after a hard comebacker off the ankle. He came in with the Phillies up 6-2 in the bottom of the ninth inning against the Washington Nationals. Paul DeJong, sporting a pencil-colored bat, set a hard line-drive ricocheting off of Durán's right ankle.
Are you seriously kidding me?? Why??! Hope Jhoan Duran is ok, but he’s in pain! #Phillies #RingTheBell.#JhoanDuran pic.twitter.com/vruXrKZDYZ
— AC (@ACinPhilly) August 16, 2025
Durán initially chased the ball toward the first base line, but as soon as it was clear he couldn't get there, he stopped dead in his tracks. The hard-throwing righty was unable to put pressure on his bum foot.
After a torturous seven-minute stint of hapless wondering, the hearts of Phillies fans sunk when the bullpen cart came out to take Durán back to the locker room.
Jhoan Duran left tonight's game in the bullpen cart after a comebacker hit him in the root foot/ankle area pic.twitter.com/eGQ1kypLqs
— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) August 16, 2025
For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the Discord to get the inside scoop during the MLB season.
Phillies fans panic after Jhoan Durán ankle injury vs. Nationals
This was naturally a cause for concern among Philadelphia fans. Durán has four shutout innings (and four saves) with only one hit allowed since the trade deadline. For a team that has so desperately needed another high-leverage arm, Durán was a dream addition for the Phillies. The 27-year-old pairs a fastball in the 100s with a nasty high-90s splinker and the occasional curveball, producing a ton of strikeouts and consistent ground-ball contact — a uniquely valuable combination.
When he came up limping, Phillies fans took to Twitter en masse for a collective grief session.
Jhoan Duran please take my foot or ankle whatever you need
— Erick (@EKlambara) August 16, 2025
PRAYER CIRCLE:
— Justin Lever ❤️⚾️ (@JustinLever3) August 16, 2025
🕯 🕯
🕯 🕯
Jhoan Duran
🕯 is Okay 🕯
🕯 🕯
🕯 🕯
Getting mad at Rob Thomson for giving Jhoan Duran some light work after he hadn’t pitched in a week:
— Austin Krell (@NBAKrell) August 16, 2025
(Also just been dying to use this clip.) pic.twitter.com/V7fF4eGtRW
Of all of the things to get mad at Rob Thomson for, Jhoan Duran pitching tonight isn’t one of them.
— Buzz (@dan_wilson4) August 16, 2025
He always says that with the 3-batter minimum, he treats anything 4 runs or fewer like a save situation. Duran also hadn’t pitched since Sunday.
It sucks, but not on the manager.
This was an emotional moment for the Phillies faithful, which naturally meant Rob Thomson came under immediate fire in some sections of the fandom. It was not technically a save situation for Durán, so many questioned why he was on the field to begin with.
Unfortunately, this was just bad luck — not a case of mismanagement from Topper. While it's only natural to want someone to blame, injuries happen. Durán hasn't pitched in a week and it was only a four-run lead, which means one hit (like Paul DeJong's leadoff infield single) would've turned it into a save situation. Thomson has long said he views four-run leads as a save situation in the ninth because of the three-batter rule, which is a totally reasonable opinion.
David Robertson managed to step in and pick up the save in a pinch, but Phillies fans are only concerned about Durán's ankle right now.
Phillies cannot afford extended absence from Jhoan Durán
It goes without saying that the Phillies reeeeally need Durán to be okay. He has the lifeblood of a vulnerable bullpen and by far their most dependable arm in late-game, high-leverage situations. Without Durán, the Phillies' bullpen regresses from a source of strength to a potential liability.
That said, there is good news on the Durán front. He was able to leave the X-ray room under his own power, per Scott Lauber of the Philadelphia Inquirer. There is still a lot unknown about Durán's condition, but he wasn't sped to the hospital for surgery on a broken bone, which is (hopefully) a positive sign.
Jhoan Duran emerged from the X-ray, walked on his own power with head athletic trainer Paul Buchheit, and went into the training room for treatment.
— Scott Lauber (@ScottLauber) August 16, 2025
Here's to hoping this is only a minor setback for Durán, because if it's anything serious... the Phillies are in trouble.