Yankees can put an early squeeze on AL East in Orioles showdown

Unless your season is actively burning to the ground in front of you — not that the New York Mets would know anything about that at the moment — it feels premature bordering on irresponsible to label any series at the beginning of May as "decisive". There are five full months and some 130 games of baseball left to be played, after all.

And yet, it sure feels like the three-game set this weekend between the New York Yankees and Baltimore Orioles is going to tell us a lot about the shape of the AL East race to come. New York enters Friday's series opener with just a 1.5-game lead over the Tampa Bay Rays for the division lead; but anyone who's been paying attention over the last couple of weeks knows that the gap feels a lot wider than that.

The only other team currently above .500 in the East is the Rays, who currently sport a negative run differential and don't seem, on paper at least, to boast the depth of talent necessary to win 90-plus games. The Jays are just trying to keep their heads above water amid an almost comical rash of injuries. The Red Sox are in a tailspin, and just got swept at home by New York a week ago.

A lot can change over a long summer, of course. But right now, it seems like the team with the best chance of actually making this a competitive race would be the O's. Which is what makes this weekend feel a bit larger than usual: However bumpy their start, Baltimore has a chance to vault itself right back into the thick of things; then again, if things break the other way, the Yankees might just reach escape velocity — and finally put (some of) the doubters to rest.

A stress test for the Orioles amid a bumpy start

How you view the Orioles' season so far depends on how you want to view the Orioles' season. If you're inclined toward optimism — or you're a close personal friend of Mike Elias — you could point out that this has been a top-10 offense of late, with even more room to grow. Adley Rutschman is finally back healthy and absolutely tearing the cover off the ball. Taylor Ward has been exactly what the team hoped when it acquired him over the winter. And Baltimore has done all of this without getting Gunnar Henderson, Pete Alonso and Samuel Basallo all rolling at the same time. It's not an exaggeration to say that this could be one of the better lineups in the sport at maximum capacity.

Of course, if you're inclined toward pessimism, you could point out that, despite an offseason in which they made multiple moves geared toward addressing the problem, this pitching staff remains an eyesore — 21st in team ERA so far this season. It hasn't come together for Shane Baz, Trevor Rogers has regressed to the mean and Chris Bassitt looks every bit his 36 years of age. The bullpen has been a pleasant surprise, but unless Baltimore's rotation bets start cashing, there just aren't enough bullets here.

So, which Orioles team are we actually going to get? One with a powerhouse offense good enough to lift a pitching staff that can at least fight its way to average (or slightly above)? Or something mired in mediocrity, not good enough in any one area to truly distinguish itself?

This weekend could well provide the answer, whether Baltimore is ready or not. Because if they aren't ready for prime time and get swept, that's an eight-game hole in the division that will be awfully difficult to climb out of. Heck, even losing two of three puts them behind the 8-ball. Start providing some proof of concept, though, and you can hit the summer well within shouting distance of first place — and plenty of reason to believe that this experiment is worth seeing through.

Can the Yankees put the hammer down where they've failed in the past?

You'll forgive Yankees fans for developing a bit of a complex in recent years. No matter how good things might look from the outside, it's become tough to let your guard down with this team — largely because things have had a habit of falling apart at a moment's notice during the Aaron Judge era. Just look at last season, when New York appeared to be cruising toward the top seed in the AL ... only to collapse into a midsummer swoon that wound up ultimately handing the division to the Blue Jays via head-to-head tiebreaker.

Once again, the Yankees find themselves at the top of the AL in the early going, clearly the best team in the league through 30ish games. The rotation is lights-out, the lineup has begun rounding into form and New York's ceiling seems higher than anybody else (especially given the dysfunction that has plagued this division so far). And now we come to a fork in the road: Can an organization that's seemed allergic to making things easy, you know, actually make things easy? Or will they turn a division that appears right there for the taking into another nip-and-tuck affair?

One series in early May won't settle that question entirely. But given the holes that Toronto and Boston have already dug for themselves, burying Baltimore would be a tremendous statement of intent. It would also do some serious damage in the standings, guaranteeing that they'll exit the weekend no worse than six games up on all three of the teams that were viewed as their stiffest competition before Opening Day. If this time really is different, this is a moment in which the Yankees will put their foot down. Time to figure out how much they've really grown from past failures.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow