Inside Fantasy Football's first known Sicko League: Daniel Jones should thrive

What is a sicko league in fantasy football? Let me explain.
Green Bay Packers v Indianapolis Colts - NFL Preseason 2025
Green Bay Packers v Indianapolis Colts - NFL Preseason 2025 | Michael Hickey/GettyImages

Most fantasy football leagues focus on the best players in the NFL. In such a league, Ja'Marr Chase, Justin Jefferson, Bijan Robinson and Jahmyr Gibbs are the players you'd want to take. Said NFL stars are sure to put up the most points week-in and week-out. But this is not that league. No, in the sicko league we focus on the worst of the worst.

Which players will play long enough – and poorly enough – to win in a league predicated on bad football? What makes the sicko league so unique isn't just that it doesn't exist in any other format, but that it rewards player attributes fantasy football managers would typically want to avoid. The scoring system demands interceptions, carries of less than three yards and targets that don't result in a catch. Finding players who will thrive in such a system is no easy task, which is why the waiver wire is all the more important.

Fantasy Football sicko league scoring system, explained

Quarterbacks are encouraged to throw for fewer yards, more incompletions and, if you're lucky, interceptions. The best QBs in the sicko league will start enough games to make a difference, but ultimately be benched late in the season. If you're lucky, your quarterback will thrive on the Daniel Jones scoring line – just bad enough to secure points on a week-to-week basis, but not so horrible that they are benched outright. That, of course, would lead to a waiver wire pickup of Anthony Richardson if you're lucky.

Statistic

Score

Passing Yards

-0.04

Each Pass Completed

-0.5

Each Incomplete Pass

1.5

TD Pass

-3

Interceptions Thrown

8

Sack

4

The best possible sicko league quarterback is sacked frequently, holds onto the ball far too long, and rarely finds their best wide receiver.

Running backs face a similar theme. Rushing yards are discouraged, as are touchdowns. Rushing attempts do help the overall scorelines, but only if those attempts go for less than, say, three yards per carry. Again, most running backs won't keep their starting job if they average under three yards per carry, so the best possible outcome is a back who has a starting role, but fails to make much of an impact. In this sense, Tony Pollard or Javonte Williams are ideal picks because they have done just enough to receive consistent carries, but are unlikely to break a long touchdown run. Former Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott was a top selection in his later years, for example.

Statistic

Score

Rushing yards

-0.4

Rushing attempts

2

Rushing touchdown

-3

As for wide receivers, it's a much tougher assignment. Which wideouts receive the most targets, but have a low YAC? Also, wide receivers who rarely score touchdowns are appreciated in this environment. The sicko league is a safe space for the likes of Diontae Johnson should he make a team, or JuJu Smith-Schuster.

Statistic

Score

Receiving Yards

-0.5

Reception

-4

Touchdown reception

-5

100-199 yard receiving game

-15

200+ yard receiving game

-20

Receiving Target

8

Defensive scoring admittedly took us a few seasons to work out. The best defenses tend to hold teams to fewer points. Thus, we want to reward defense which give up the most points. The same can be said for yards allowed. If a defense gives up over 500 yards, they should be rewarded for doing so. Any defense or special teams that records a 1-point safety essentially wins the game (1,000 points), because how in the world does that even happen?

Statistic

Score

Sack

-0.5

Interception

-1

Fumble recovered

-1

0 points allowed

-5

1-6 points allowed

-4

7-13 points allowed

-3

14-17 points allowed

-1

18-21 points allowed

1

22-27 points allowed

5

28-34 points allowed

10

35-45 points allowed

12

46+ points allowed

16

Less than 100 total yards allowed

-6

100-199 total yards allowed

-5

200-299 total yards allowed

-3

300-349 total yards allowed

1

350-399 total yards allowed

2

400-449 total yards allowed

4

450-499 total yards allowed

8

500-549 total yards allowed

10

550+ total yards allowed

12

In this league, kickers and punters are hot commodities. If a kicker misses a short field goal attempt, we appreciate them for trying in the first place. If they miss an extra point, you've struck gold. As for punters, the goal is to reward the best punts possible. Touchbacks are a moot point, but a punt inside the 20-yard line will help your overall scoreline. Punters may not be household names for you, personally, but I am very aware what Panthers punter Sam Martin is doing on a daily basis.

Statistic

Score

Each PAT Made

-0.1

Each PAT Missed

15

FG Made (0-39 yards)

-0.2

FG Made (40-49 yards)

-0.5

FG Missed (0-39 yards)

10

FG Missed (40-49 yards)

7

FG Missed (50-59 yards)

3

FG Made (50-59 yards)

-1

FG Made (60+ yards)

-8

FG Missed (60+ yards)

2

Punt Yards

0.03

Punts Inside the 10

2

Punt Return Yards

-0.05

Touchbacks

1

Sicko Fantasy Football League draft: Who were the hot commodities?

For anyone interested in their own sicko league, finding the right players to pick is key. For example, players on the worst teams are typically an easy option. Justin Fields, Cam Ward and Tony Pollard are the top-projected scorers in my league for Week 1, in part because they have tough opponents and they play for the New York Jets and Tennessee Titans. My team features three players on the Titans, three on the Saints, two on the Browns and so forth.

ESPN – which hosted our league without their knowledge – graded most of our drafts poorly. That is a great sign given the scoring system rewards the worst possible teams. You should aim low, and consider which players will start for a considerable period of time while playing poorly. I cannot stress that enough. Here were the first 20 picks of our draft, as an example.

Pick

Player

1

Joe Flacco, QB

2

Ja'Marr Chase (autopick, blame my cousin)

3

Cam Ward

4

Javonte Williams

5

Sam Darnold

6

Tony Pollard

7

Kenny Pickett

8

Chuba Hubbard

9

Corey Bojorquez (P)

10

Ollie Gordon II

11

David Njoku

12

Travis Etienne Jr.

13

Austin McNamara (P)

14

Sam Martin (P)

15

Adam Thielen

16

Ashton Jeanty

17

Breece Hall

18

Tommy Townsend

19

Aaron Jones Sr.

20

Wan'Dale Robinson

What a Sicko League starting lineup looks like

An ideal sicko league starting lineup follows the same strategy of a normal fantasy football league lineup. You have one quarterback, two running backs, two wide receivers, a flex player, a tight end, a defense, kicker and punter. The goal is to get the most points, rather than the least, which the scoring system might suggest. Contrary to my own belief, the scoring system is set up to reward the worst players and penalize the best. That is the whole point of the league and the draft as a whole.

Here is my team's starting lineup for Week 1. Also, if you're doing this right, you might as well name your team after an NFL sicko legend. In my case, that's Jeff Fisher Dream Team.

Position

Player

QB

Daniel Jones

RB

Tony Pollard

RB

D'Andre Swift

WR

Cedric Tillman

WR

Brandin Cooks

FLEX

Alvin Kamara

TE

David Njoku

DEFENSE

Raiders

K

Tyler Bass

P

Sam Martin

Can some of these players perform well in both the sicko and traditional fantasy football leagues? Sure. But if so, you might as well ask the commissioner why that's the case. Again, all of these players were drafted to play poorly. Most play on bad teams, too!

Enjoy your football weekend, and remember: It's never too late to create a sicko league. Let's keep this trend going strong.