It's not exactly breaking news to say that DK Metcalf is talented. Back in 2019, the 6-foot-4 receiver ran a 4.33-second 40-yard dash and posted a 40.5-inch vertical at the combine. Metcalf is one of the most athletic wideouts in the league and has been a star from the moment he stepped foot on an NFL field. He has racked up over 6,000 yards for his career and has already established himself as Aaron Rodgers' favorite target in his first year with the Pittsburgh Steelers.
Despite his immense talent, Metcalf's temper has gotten in the way. Whether it's getting overly chippy with defensive players or crashing out on the sidelines, this has been an underlying issue for DK that his talent has typically overshadowed. During Sunday night's game against the Green Bay Packers, Metcalf had one of his famous moments when he poked Quay Walker near the eye region.
DK Metcalf called for personal foul for this pic.twitter.com/BF3wOb8Zwr
— Rate the Refs (@Rate_the_Refs) October 27, 2025
Metcalf received a 15-yard personal foul penalty for this foolish play, something that hurt the Steelers as they tried to mount a fourth-quarter comeback. Seattle Seahawks fans quickly grew annoyed with Metcalf's antics and know the Steelers are starting to realize the negative side of DK.
DK Metcalf needs to control his temper for the Steelers
It would be ridiculous to say that Metcalf's actions cost the Steelers the game. However, these little frustrations plays add up and at some point they might cost the Steelers in a real way. Metcalf is now 27 years old and is in his seventh year in the league. He simply has to mature. It's difficult to trust someone in high-leverage situations who is constantly getting into conflicts with opponents and regularly crashes out on the sidelines.
I'm willing to give him some grace for these moments earlier in his career. But in year seven, it's no longer acceptable. These type of plays hurt the team and his reputation. Mike Tomlin should make it clear that this isn't acceptable and that DK must change his actions.
Again, I have to wonder what the reaction is if a moment like this happens in the playoffs. Additionally, it gives opponents a blueprint on how to get the upper hand over him. I'm also sure defensive players know they can get into Metcalf's head and bait him into committing stupid plays. Right now, Metcalf is as easy to provoke into doing something foolish as Tommy in Goodfellas. The brighter the stage, the bigger this problem could get.
Overall, Metcalf needs to clean up his act fast, or it will eventually cost him and the Steelers.
The DK Metcalf trade in retrospect
Given this, it's fair to wonder if the Steelers are regretting trading for DK back in March. Pittsburgh gave Seattle a second and seventh-round pick to land Metcalf, who had requested a trade. Following this, they signed Metcalf to a five-year $150 million contract extension. Additionally, the Steelers traded George Pickens and a sixth-round pick to the Dallas Cowboys for a third and fifth-round pick. Side note, but that receiver duo would have been fun to watch. Like Metcalf, Pickens is talented but has a short temper.
Ultimately, I don't think the Steelers should regret trading for Metcalf. They desperately needed a WR1, and Metcalf was likely the best option. Deebo Samuel could have been an intriguing lower-cost option. However, he's not the deep threat that Metcalf is.
Metcalf has largely lived up to his WR1 status. He is on pace for 1,119 yards and 12 touchdowns. Nevertheless, the price was a bit rich given the context that Metcalf requested a trade and wanted a new contract.
Similarly, I do think the extension was a bit too pricey contract-wise. For reference, he will be the fourth-highest-paid receiver next year. Metcalf is a top-10 or 15 level receiver, but not top-five. This, when paired with his antics, makes this deal less than ideal. Trading for DK wasn't a bad move, but it wasn't a perfect one either, and his attitude problems need to be mentioned.
From the Seahawks' perspective, they got strong value in return for the disgruntled receiver. In his absence, Jaxon Smith-Njigba has blossomed into an elite WR1.
More NFL news and analysis: