Alabama wasn't content with the product Jalen Milroe put on the field against Texas. So Nick Saban benched the two-game starter in favor of backup Tyler Buchner.
The Notre Dame transfer was supposed to spark the Crimson Tide with better pocket presence and decision-making. And to his credit, he didn't make any major mistakes early against USF. He just looked terrrible in every other way.
After just one quarter, Alabama fans on Twitter were ready to bench Buchner for literally any other quarterback on the roster.
Bench Tyler Buchner: Alabama fans are done with the new starting quarterback
šØMELTDOWN ALERT šØ#Alabama is down 3-0. #MeltdownAlert pic.twitter.com/jGKnptJ2RV
ā Message Board Geniuses (@BoardGeniuses) September 16, 2023
yeaaaa tyler buchner aināt it
ā Hilary Banks. (@_KISSMEimyellow) September 16, 2023
Even Milroeās intās last week looked better than any pass Buchner has thrown today.
ā BamaSteelĀ® (@djTide2013) September 16, 2023
Send Tyler Buchner to the bench ASAP.
ā Justin (@NameIsJustin3) September 16, 2023
Milroe after Buchnerās first drive: pic.twitter.com/fDaC2u8PzS
ā Gabriel Hardin (@gabrielhardin) September 16, 2023
If Milroe isnāt the answer, I am sorry but it 100% isnāt Tyler Buchner.
ā Sidelines - Bama (@SSN_Alabama) September 16, 2023
College football Twitter joined the Buchner pile on.
Buchner would lose the Dr. Pepper pass competition
ā Transfer Portal (@NCAAPortal) September 16, 2023
USF quarterback Byrum Brown is 4 of 8 for 29 yards today. He has a better stat line than Alabamaās Tyler Buchner.
ā Robert Behrens (@rcb05) September 16, 2023
So ... Tyler Buchner might not be the answer.
ā Stewart Mandel (@slmandel) September 16, 2023
After one quarter, Buchner was 4-of-9 for 25 yards, but even his completed passes often put the receivers in tough spots. His incompletions were often behind or out of range of receivers.
The best moment of the first quarter for the QB by far was a short gain on a keeper to convert a third down. And that should come as no surprise. Buchner's legs were his greatest asset at Notre Dame.
But Alabama needs more than just the occassional bright run from Buchner. That's why they benched Milroe, because his rushing ability didn't make up for bad decisions in the passing game.
The Crimson Tide had to punt on each of their first four drives and Buchner was at the root of those stalled drives. The only thing working in Buchner's favor may be the worsening weather. Alabama leaning on the ground game, with handoffs and keepers, could get the offense rolling.
Who could Saban turn to next? Former five-star prospect Ty Simson is on the bench along with freshman Dylan Lonergan. At this rate, Alabama may have to make another quarterback change if they want to avoid a shocking upset at the hands of USF.