Scott Boras has a reputation. Forget your team-friendly deals. Forget value signings. He's singularly focused on getting his clients max dollars. Scott Boras and big-money deals go hand-in-hand.
Well, that used to be Boras' reputation. Because his image is taking a hit in 2024.
Boras went into MLB free agency this year with big clients looking for a payday, including the so-called "Boras 4" of Blake Snell, Cody Bellinger, Jordan Montgomery and Matt Chapman.
All four ended up in prolonged stalemates with teams who weren't willing to pay them even close to what Boras was asking. Three of them have now signed contracts for less money with opt-outs that could essentially restart the process next year. Snell and Montgomery have missed just about all of spring training.
On Monday, Snell finally agreed to a two-year contract with the Giants with an opt-out after the first year. For a 31-year-old reigning Cy Young winner, that's a weak outcome, even if he got the +$30 million AAV he was looking for. A Cy Young season should get you some future financial security. Snell just settled for what amounts to a one-year show-me deal.
MLB Twitter had things to say about Boras' handling of the whole saga.
Best memes and tweets dragging Scott Boras over Blake Snell deal
Cody Bellinger wanted $200+ million got $80 million
— Eric Katz #repbx (@Sportsteamnews) March 19, 2024
Matt Chapman wanted $150 million got $54 million
Blake Snell wanted $270 million and got $62 million
Jordan Montgomery is still unsigned
The mighty Scott Boras struck out this offseason and there was no joy at Boras Corp
Seeking $270/9, turned down $150/6, and accepted $62/2.
— anthony (@HoodieAlonso) March 19, 2024
Scott Boras everybody🔥🔥🔥🔥 pic.twitter.com/tr46KCIyXy
Scott Boras’ clients after this offseason… #BlueJays #MLB pic.twitter.com/NWzEUfYG4i
— Scott BlueJaysAlways (@BluejaysAlways) March 19, 2024
Scott Boras cooking this offseason pic.twitter.com/SGalzjKJ8B
— BetMGM 🦁 (@BetMGM) March 19, 2024
Yamamoto: never pitched a day in MLB in his life, gets a deal that goes through his age 37 season
— vinnie (@VinRBI) March 19, 2024
Blake Snell: Reigning and 2 time Cy Young winner, gets a deal through his age 33 season
Scott Boras is TERRIBLE
Scott Boras when AJ Preller doesn’t have any money to carelessly spend pic.twitter.com/wATyRItVaf
— John (@Friar_Faithful) March 19, 2024
It's not just about the money with Boras. It's about how these deals came about (or are still waiting to come about, in the case of Montgomery). Boras set up a scenario where his clients signed short-term deals with the hopes of cashing after opt-outs. But their preseason preparations were disrupted by the lengthy negotiating process. They're all off on the wrong foot heading into a season that matters even more when it comes to their financial future.
Will any players considering signing with Boras look at this offseason and change their minds about their potential agent? We'll see.
Next. 4 teams that should save Braves All-Star Bryce Elder from the minor leagues. 4 teams that should save Bryce Elder from minor leagues. dark