The Colorado Rockies' firing of Bud Black was far from shocking. The team, even after its win on Sunday, is now 7-33 with a -128 run differential - both marks are the worst in the majors by far. Conversations about this Rockies team ultimately being one of the worst in MLB history have already begun. Even with the firing, Rockies fans aren't content with where the franchise is right now as long as the Monfort family owns the team.
— Colorado Rockies (@Rockies) May 11, 2025
Sure, Black did not get the job done as manager. He had gone just 544-690 during parts of nine seasons with Colorado. The team had just two winning seasons under Black, and those came in his first two years managing the club.
However, how much of that was actually on Black? The Monfort's have seemingly run this franchise into the ground, but since they're the owners, they won't be going anywhere.
For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the discord to get the inside scoop during the MLB season.
Rockies fans know the real problem has no realistic solution
relieve dick monfort of his duties PLEASE
— burly (@burlyknoll) May 11, 2025
Many of the replies to Colorado's statement on the Black firing are like this one. The fans are begging for Dick Monfort to be relieved of his duties as the owner. Unfortunately, with Monfort being the only one who could let himself go, Rockies fans are stuck with him.
Nothing will distract us from the absolute terrible ownership of the Rockies. Fire all the managers you can. Monfort sucks.
— Paul Prosise (@PaulProsise) May 11, 2025
Black was far from perfect during his Rockies tenure. I mean, the record speaks for itself. However, what was he supposed to do with the current iteration of the Rockies to make this team any better? Their pitching, as always, is a mess, and despite playing half the time at Coors Field, the Rockies rank second-to-last in runs scored. This team has no strengths, and that isn't Bud Black's fault. Rockies fans know that better than anyone.
lol. Bud black isn’t the issues. Ownership and front office have been an embarrassment for how long now? But sure….
— Cameron Jaymes (@cameronjaymes) May 11, 2025
The fault instead lies more with GM Bill Schmidt and, especially, the Monfort family. They have positioned this team to fail, and that's exactly what's happened.
Rockies highest-paid players:
— Danny Vietti (@DannyVietti) May 8, 2025
$27M
Kris Bryant: .154 BA, IL
$16M
Kyle Freeland: 0-4, 6.41 ERA
$12M
Ryan McMahon: .192 BA/.660 OPS
$12M
Antonio Senzatela: 1-5, 5.50 ERA
$10M
Germán Márquez: 0-6, 9.90 ERA
$6.3M
Austin Gomber: IL
$5M
Nolan Arenado: traded to STL
The Rockies might have spent more money than many of the league's small-market teams, but that money has not been spent wisely at all. If Anthony Rendon's contract did not exist, Kris Bryant's albatross would be getting much more publicity than it already has. All of their highest-paid players have been major disappointments. How does Schmidt still have a job?
Did Black deserve to get fired? Probably. Could anyone do a better job? Maybe, but not much better. The Rockies got rid of the slightest bit of where the problem truly lies. Schmidt is a lot more responsible than Black, and Monfort, obviously, deserves the biggest piece of the blame pie. Unfortunately, where real change can take place, no moves will be made.