This may be the worst day in Florida State football history. Despite going 12-0 on the season, 8-0 in ACC play, beating two Power Five teams in the non-conference (LSU and Florida), and beating Louisville to win the ACC Championship Game in Charlotte to improve to 13-0, the Seminoles were not good enough to make the final-four team College Football Playoff. Alabama got in over them...
Six teams were still alive for it entering Selection Sunday. Georgia was on life support, but didn't make it as the previous winners of the last two playoffs fell short by a field goal in Atlanta to Alabama. While Michigan and Washington were locks at 13-0 winning their respective Power Five leagues, the final two spots went to Big 12 Champion Texas and SEC Champion Alabama over the ACC Champions.
This has everything to do with the four best teams vs. most deserving debate. Florida State would have made it had starting quarterback Jordan Travis not gotten hurt vs. North Alabama. Having his backup Tate Rodemaker suffer a concussion vs. Florida, the Seminoles may have had a chance, too. Despite beating Louisville 16-6 in Charlotte, third-stringer Brock Glenn struggled mightily for FSU.
It sucks, but it came down to this: Florida State was viewed as a different team with Travis and Rodemaker out. It is why the CFP went with teams like Alabama and Texas over the Seminoles...
Florida State misses out on College Football Playoff despite being 13-0
This was the most difficult decision ever made in College Football Playoff history. It is more controversial than leaving both Big 12 co-champions Baylor and TCU out over eventual national champion Alabama in 2014. What happened on Sunday afternoon makes seeing a two-loss Big Ten champion Penn State team miss out in favor of Ohio State as an at-large look like small potatoes.
THE FLORIDA STATE SEMINOLES HAVE BEEN ELIMINATED FROM THE COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF pic.twitter.com/qqcVN0Bs2c
— RedditCFB (@RedditCFB) December 3, 2023
The goal is winning all your football games. Florida State did that. I understand the QB situation isn't excellent and they probably aren't better than Alabama right now. But now you're punishing FSU for their Qb getting hurt. Feels wrong
— Geoff Schwartz (@geoffschwartz) December 3, 2023
Florida State, 13-0 and ACC champions, left out of the CFP. That is stunning.
— Nicole Auerbach (@NicoleAuerbach) December 3, 2023
Florida State and Georgia have been LEFT OUT of the #CFBPlayoff 😮 pic.twitter.com/2ciaHhbC5q
— ESPN College Football (@ESPNCFB) December 3, 2023
I would be lying to you otherwise, but somebody was going to be screwed over big time in the final four-team playoff. All five Power Five champions had a great shot at getting in. The fact we had four undefeated teams heading into Championship Weekend was inevitably going to end up in great disappointment for someone. Simply, Florida State was never going to pass the proverbial eye test.
just brutal for Florida State. won em all and lost a beauty pageant. won em all.
— Matt Hinton (@MattRHinton) December 3, 2023
The CFP selection committee decided to screw Florida State.
— Robert Griffin III (@RGIII) December 3, 2023
If you're going with the best teams, I understand Alabama.
— Chris Vannini (@ChrisVannini) December 3, 2023
I just can't believe the committee put undefeated Florida State's heartbreak completely on Jordan Travis. Absolutely gutted for him and that team.
I feel terrible for Florida State. Damn.
— Field Yates (@FieldYates) December 3, 2023
If there are any positives to take away from this, there are two things. One, we are going to a 12-team format next year, so teams like Florida State and Georgia who got left out would be hosting home games at Doak Campbell and Sanford between the No. 12 and No. 11 seeds, respectively. The heartbreak is never going to feel like this again. We do feel for you big time in this, Florida State fans.
Florida State’s reaction to the Top Four
— Barstool Sports (@barstoolsports) December 3, 2023
pic.twitter.com/gt4KvSnvLN
Florida State scheduled an SEC powerhouse. They won a power five conference. They won all their games, overcoming adversity along the way. This isn’t figure skating, judges should never have been a part of it. #FSU #CFP
— Mike Greenberg (@Espngreeny) December 3, 2023
Remember, Florida State fans, this is Hugh Freeze’s fault.
— Bunkie Perkins (@BunkiePerkins) December 3, 2023
You can’t say Bama is better than Florida State due to injuries but also say FSU is better than Georgia.
— Jon Tweets Sports (@jontweetssports) December 3, 2023
The CFP committee just made it up.
Unfortunately, you have to remember what this is at its core. This is a TV show. ESPN is the lone broadcaster of the College Football Playoff. Despite being a massive brand out of the ACC, Florida State would have had no chance vs. Michigan. As far as Alabama is concerned, it would not shock me if they won. All four teams who made it in can win the national championship. Florida State could not.
Florida State will get to play in the Orange Bowl, but they coveted some sugar or maybe some roses...