For the second straight contest, Oklahoma City Thunder wing Alex Caruso finds himself at the center of a controversial foul call. Oddly enough, it was a near-identical situation, but the officials in Game 3 saw it differently from the crew in Game 4. Things like this happen when the NBA turns to referee Scott "The Extender" Foster, though that doesn't make Indiana Pacers fans feel any better.
A turnover by Pacers star point guard Tyrese Haliburton midway through the second quarter resulted in a Caruso fast-break opportunity the other way. Considering this is the Finals, Indiana's Obi Toppin tried to do what he could to prevent an easy layup. However, the high-flying big man may have been a little too physical, at least according to Foster and his fellow refs.
Obi Toppin was charged with a Flagrant 1 foul on this play.
— ESPN (@espn) June 14, 2025
Toppin and Isaiah Hartenstein received double technicals after review. pic.twitter.com/gxWlv4Xioo
Foster deemed Toppin's contact a "non-basketball play," triggering a Flagrant 1 foul that riled up Pacers fans everywhere.
Pacers fans can't believe Scott Foster's flagrant ruling in Game 4
Scott Foster booed by Pacers fans after officials rule Obi Toppin’s foul a flagrant 1, which was followed by technical fouls on Toppin on Isaiah Hartenstein.
— ClutchPoints (@ClutchPoints) June 14, 2025
(via @TomerAzarly) pic.twitter.com/im9CO70auU
After review, Foster couldn't even finish his sentence before being serenaded by booes from the Indiana faithful in attendance at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. The "Cob Mob" made it well-known that they were not happy with the ruling.
This was not called a flagrant foul on Aaron Nesmith in Game 3.
— BKS Sports (@BKSecretsports) June 14, 2025
The video above was called a flagrant foul on Obi Toppin, super confused on the refs logic. They have no idea what they’re doing. https://t.co/PwPLgGIIMq pic.twitter.com/BEmduMoi7F
Everyone watching had a sense of déjà vu after watching Caruso running down the floor with a head of steam and a Pacers defender trailing. We just saw a similar occurrence roughly 48 hours ago with him and Indiana swingman Aaron Nesmith, which was ultimately only a common foul. The inconsistency speaks to how Foster and the zebras "have no idea what they're doing," as this X (formerly known as Twitter) user claims. Thunder fans were upset about how the first instance was officiated, so consider this a makeup call.
This was deemed a flagrant foul penalty 1 on Obi Toppin.
— Alex Golden (@AlexGoldenNBA) June 14, 2025
Toppin and Hartenstein were both given Technical Fouls as well.
Ridiculous flagrant foul call. pic.twitter.com/kUAODB3qfH
Setting the Pace's Alex Golden declared the Flagrant 1 on Toppin and double technical assessed to him and Thunder center Isaiah Hartenstein "ridiculous." And frankly, when factoring in the Nesmith verdict, it's hard to disagree; he wrapped Caruso up from behind while Toppin was running alongside OKC's sparkplug.
This isn’t a flagrant foul I’m sorry . Obi toppin bumps Alex Caruso hard enough so he doesn’t get off a shot and then swipes at the ball pic.twitter.com/w71h6gaOkW
— John (@iam_johnw) June 14, 2025
There's no need to apologize, John -- your frustration is warranted. Toppin committed a good, hard playoff foul on the Association's grandest stage. It was a bang-bang play, and the whistle went in favor of the Thunder.
Obi Toppin, Pacers quickly get makeup call from Scott Foster in Game 4 of NBA Finals
Toppin was fouled on a drive to the paint that was abruptly halted by the Thunder's Luguentz Dort roughly four minutes of game time later. Foster went to the monitor (again) and decided that the criteria for a Flagrant 1 were met. Both sides picked up an infraction they probably shouldn't have, so no harm, no foul, we suppose (pun intended).
Lu Dort was assessed a Flagrant 1 foul against Obi Toppin on this play.#NBAFinals pic.twitter.com/FaPZH58CSH
— TSN (@TSN_Sports) June 14, 2025
You be the judge. Do these calls look appropriate?