Fansided

3 Darius Garland trades the Cavs need to make if they re-sign Donovan Mitchell

Donovan Mitchell is reportedly leaning toward signing an extension with the Cavs which may force them to trade Darius Garland. Here's how they can make the most of a tough situation.
May 15, 2024; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Cleveland Cavaliers guard Darius Garland (10) drives to the basket
May 15, 2024; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Cleveland Cavaliers guard Darius Garland (10) drives to the basket | David Butler II-USA TODAY Sports

Following their second-round exit playoff exit rumors are beginning to swirl around the Cleveland Cavaliers offseason and future. It's been rumored if the Cavs can extend Donovan Mitchell then backcourt co-star Darius Garland will be out the door.

Additionally, it appears more likely that Mitchell will re-sign in Cleveland than previously believed. The Cavs' pairing of two undersized guards and two non-spacing big men in Evan Mobley and Jarrett Allen was clearly flawed. This offseason gives the Cavs an opportunity to reset their roster with more balance around Mitchell.

Here are three options to turn Darius Garland into a player who fits better next to Donovan Mitchell.

3. Pelicans-Cavs swap stars

A Brandon Ingram-Garland swap makes sense for all sides involved. Both stars are likely to be traded this offseason and have similar trade values. Pairing an All-Star wing next to Mitchell is ideal and would give the Cavs more balance than in years past. The Cavs would now have an All-Star level guard, wing, and bigĀ makingĀ them a much more well-rounded squad.

While Ingram had a poor postseason this yearĀ averagingĀ just 14Ā pointsĀ on 40 percent shooting from theĀ field, he’sĀ had good playoff performancesĀ in the past. That includesĀ a 2022 first-round series against theĀ SunsĀ where Ingram averaged 27 points, 6.2 rebounds, 6.2Ā assists while shooting 47 percent from the field and 40Ā percent on 3-pointers.Ā 

FromĀ Ingram’sĀ perspective,Ā he’sĀ never played next to an elite guard like MitchellĀ whichĀ willĀ surelyĀ elevate his game.Ā Furthermore, he will be the clear second option on the CavsĀ whichĀ appears to be his ideal role as an elite secondary scorer. Ingram will have far less offensive pressure with the Cavs andĀ willĀ thrive in this role.

The Pelicans would get a much-needed guard and elite playmaker next to Zion Williamson. With a Brandon Ingram trade seeming ike a certainty, this trade gives the Pelicans a perfect opportunity to land a much-needed lead guard. They also have a plethora of elite wing defenders to surround Garland with. UltimatelyĀ thisĀ swap would be a no-brainer for both teams.Ā 

2. Garland to the Magic, Bridges to the Cavs in three team blockbuster

TheĀ Magic’sĀ need forĀ a trueĀ lead guard and 3-point shooting was onĀ fullĀ display during the playoffs. Garland has the exact skill set Orlando desires and, as a result, they will likely target him if made available. However, the Magic can only offer an intriguing rebuilding packageĀ makingĀ the inclusion of a third team necessary.

The Nets are the perfect third team to facilitate a deal. Brooklyn isĀ veryĀ mediocre and without their own pick in the NBA Draft until 2028. As a result, cashing in on their top assetĀ MikalĀ Bridges, while getting some picks and young players in return is logical.

Similar to Ingram, Bridges gives the Cavs an ideal All-Star-level wing. However, BridgesĀ gives the CavsĀ more defense and 3-point shootingĀ as opposed toĀ shot-creation.Ā Bridges is aĀ clearĀ fitĀ next to Mitchell and withĀ theĀ Cavs’ defensive identity.Ā For the past two seasons, the Cavs have had a top-10 defensive rating,Ā ranking seventh this year and first lastĀ season.

This trade would solidify the Cavs as an elite top-five-level defenseĀ andĀ they could even regain their title as theĀ league'sĀ top defense next season. While this trade hasĀ a lot ofĀ movingĀ partsĀ it would greatly benefit all teams involved.Ā 

1. LakersĀ land a third star

The LakersĀ are likely planning toĀ target another star to pair with LeBron James and Anthony Davis this offseason. Trae Young, Dejounte Murray, Donovan Mitchell, and Brandon Ingram have allĀ been linkedĀ to the Lakers. Garland, however, might be the best fit and most realistic target. The Lakers are in desperate need of shooting and secondary creation. Garland can provide this skill set while taking onĀ a majorityĀ of the ball-handling and playmaking responsibilities.

The Lakers have mentioned getting a bona fide All-Star in exchange for Austin Reaves. Garland is aĀ one-time-All-StarĀ butĀ at 24Ā hasĀ plenty of upside and is a big enough name to make the deal work. He is also a part of Klutch Sports the same agency that represents LeBron and Davis.

For the Cavs, this trade package offers a less-is-more approach. Austin ReavesĀ isn’tĀ at the same level as GarlandĀ however, heĀ offersĀ plenty of value as both playmaker and creator. He would also be capable of playing more off-ball next to Mitchell. While Rui Hachimura struggled in theĀ playoffsĀ he still offers value as aĀ biggerĀ rotational wing with defensive and shooting capabilities.Ā 

Adding a high-level complementary guard and wing would be enough toĀ make up for the loss of GarlandĀ while balancing out the roster better.Ā Furthermore, this deal offers some insurance for the Cavs as theyĀ are receivingĀ a future first-round pick. Ultimately, this dealĀ doesn’tĀ give the Cavs an immediate star but offersĀ justĀ as many benefits as the other deals.Ā 

Schedule