Caitlin Clark’s brutal injury decision is ultimately best for Fever and superstar alike

The news nobody wanted to hear is ultimately the best possible news for Caitlin Clark and the Fever.
Indiana Fever v Phoenix Mercury
Indiana Fever v Phoenix Mercury | Christian Petersen/GettyImages

The Indiana Fever entered the 2025 WNBA season in the WNBA championship conversation. A year-two leap from Caitlin Clark paired with several big-name additions, made it feel like the sky was truly the limit for Indiana. Unfortunately, we'll never know whether Clark could've led this team to the WNBA championship this season, as she just announced that her 2025 campaign has ended prematurely due to her groin injury.

This update isn't shocking, but it's also nothing but heartbreaking. Clark is must-see TV every time she's able to suit up, and averaged 16.5 points, 5.0 rebounds and 8.5 assists per game for the Fever in 13 games this season. Watching her second WNBA season end in early September due to injury is frustrating and tough to come to terms with.

As disappointing as this update is for Clark, the Fever, and the WNBA as a whole, it's hard to shake the feeling that it's for the best.

The last thing Caitlin Clark should've done was rush back

As she wrote, Clark did everything she could to return. It just wasn't feasible. Sure, if she had to return she might've been able to at 50-ish percent, but what's the point of that? Who wants to see a severely compromised Clark struggle to play in what could very well be a lost season for her team?

Fever head coach Stephanie White perfectly summed up why shutting Clark down for the year is for the best for her and the team.

"Caitlin has worked so hard throughout this time, doing everything possible to recover and return to the court but, ultimately, time is not on our side," Fever COO and general manager Amber Cox said in a statement. "While we will continue working with Caitlin and provide her with every resource we have available, there is not enough time left in our season for her to safely return, and her long-term health and well-being remains our top priority. We are looking forward to having her back at full strength to start the 2026 season."

At the end of the day, the long-term view is important here. Clark is a 23-year-old phenom who has enjoyed unparalleled success to begin her career. It'd be nice to have seen her play this season, but what if coming back too early led to a major injury that impacted her play in 2026 and beyond?

This injury is already worse than anticipated. Rushing back from that could've led to severe consequences. This decision allows her to be healthier and better than ever ahead of what should be an exciting 2026 season for the Fever and Clark as she looks to establish herself as one of the WNBA's best players.

Fever wouldn't have gained anything from rushing Caitlin Clark back

Time was not on Indiana's side. With only three regular season games to go before the playoffs begin, what would they be rushing Clark back for little to no reason.

Sure, the Fever are in the middle of a playoff race, but what realistic chance do they have of winning it all? Four other players, headlined by Aari McDonald and Sophie Cunningham, are out for the season with injuries of their own. Even if Clark came back and was somehow at 100 percent, what are the odds that the Fever, as a likely No. 8 seed, would go on a run to the championship?

Perhaps if they were fully healthy there'd be more of a reason for Clark to rush back, but this team likely wouldn't even win a playoff round, let alone a title, with Clark playing. Again, it just isn't worth it.

It stinks and is the news nobody wants, but this is what's best for Clark and the Fever.